HP 58A Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge vs HP Smart Tank 5101 All-in-One Ink Tank Printer
What separates them
These two differ on 2 recorded specifications. The HP Smart Tank 5101 All-in-One Ink Tank Printer is $90.00 dearer. They are different kinds of product — laser toner cartridge against ink tank mfp — so read the table as two spec sheets rather than a like-for-like.
HP 58A Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge vs HP Smart Tank 5101 All-in-One Ink Tank Printer
HP
HP 58A Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge
$109.99
About 3,000 pages at ISO/IEC 19752, which is a defined 5 per cent coverage test -- ordinary office documents run closer to 6 or 7 per cent, so real yield is usually below the number on the box.
Full details →HP
HP Smart Tank 5101 All-in-One Ink Tank Printer
$199.99
Refillable tanks rather than cartridges is what changes the arithmetic: a bottle set covering roughly 6,000 black and 8,000 color pages costs about as much as one laser cartridge.
Full details →Who the HP 58A Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge is for
Buy it if: Sites running LaserJet Pro M404 or M428 machines that want the yield the printer was rated with.
Avoid it if: Higher-volume offices, who should be buying the 58X high-yield cartridge instead.
Who the HP Smart Tank 5101 All-in-One Ink Tank Printer is for
Buy it if: Home offices printing color regularly and wanting the lowest cost per color page.
Avoid it if: Sites that print in bursts weeks apart, where a laser will not clog and this will.
Specifications, side by side
2 of 18 rows differ. Differences first.
| Specification | HP 58A Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge | HP Smart Tank 5101 All-in-One Ink Tank Printer |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $109.99 | $199.99 |
| Cost per page | About 3.7 cents at the stated yield | About 0.5 cents mono and 1.5 cents color, excluding paper |
| Warranty | HP cartridge replacement guarantee | 1-year limited hardware warranty |
| Cartridge type | Toner only -- imaging drum sold separately | not published |
| Color | Black | not published |
| Compatible printers | LaserJet Pro M404, M405, M428 and M429 | not published |
| Connectivity | not published | Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and USB |
| Document feeder | not published | None -- flatbed glass only |
| Duplex | not published | Manual only |
| Duty cycle | not published | Up to 3,000 pages a month maximum |
| High-yield alternative | HP 58X, about 10,000 pages | not published |
| Page yield | About 3,000 pages at 5 per cent coverage | not published |
| Page yield per refill | not published | About 6,000 black and 8,000 color pages |
| Print resolution | not published | 1200 x 1200 dpi black, 4800 x 1200 dpi color |
| Print speed | not published | Up to 12 ppm mono, 5 ppm color, draft |
| Rated power | not published | About 12 W printing |
| Replacement ink | not published | HP 32XL black and HP 31 color bottles |
| Shelf life | About 2 years sealed | not published |
| Yield standard | ISO/IEC 19752 | not published |
Every row is a figure one or both products record. A blank is a figure the catalogue does not hold, not a zero.
Compare the HP 58A Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge with something else →